• Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Work With Me
  • Studio
  • Contact

Consumer’s Guide To Health: The Cost Of Spinal Fusion

Friday, 04 November 2011 23:21

Spine from Above DownIf there was an Olympic event for back surgery, then the United States would be a gold medalist year in and year out. The United States is not only number one in the world in back surgeries performed annually, but it is also number one in the world in failed back surgeries annually. More than 20,000 lumbar spinal fusions are performed annually in this country. There are eight times as many spinal surgical procedures are carried out in the United States per capita as in Britain. Either the United States just coincidentally happens to have a lot of bad backs, or there are a lot of surgeries being performed needlessly.

There is also a direct relationship between the number of spinal operations performed in any one geographical area and the number of orthopaedic and neurosurgeons in that area. That being the case, the likelihood of you having surgery prescribed for you is related more to the demographics of your locale than it is to "getting the patient better".

Lumbar spinal fusion is costly – from an economic standpoint, and from a societal one as well. This is a consumer issue with some staggering numbers and facts.

The cost of a spinal fusion has a price tag of around $45,000. With 20,000 being performed annually, you are now looking at a total of $900,000,000 in surgeries alone. As for failed spinal surgeries, the numbers are staggering as well - a cost of $2 billion per year. That is a lot of money being spent on surgeries that are either unnecessary or that have failed.

As is the case for many medical conditions, the scientific literature does not support the value of lumbar spinal fusion. In a study by Chou et al (2009), it was reported that spinal fusion is no more effective than intensive rehabilitation, but it is associated with “small to moderate benefits compared to standard non-surgical therapy”. In a study from the British Medical Journal in 1996, Wilson-MacDonald stated that "The case for spinal fusion is unproved".

So how does the consumer know what to do? Who is telling the truth? Who do I trust – the doctor or the science?

There are three readily accepted reasons for performing a spinal fusion that are consistent in the scientific literature and current clinical guidelines: intractable pain (failing conservative treatment), worsening neurological symptoms in the lower extremity, and bowel or bladder symptoms. Yes, health care providers do come across patients that fit the bill here – though not nearly as frequently as the annual spinal fusion statistics might indicate. In today’s world, if you have back pain, and only back pain, the scientific literature would indicate that you should rarely (if ever) be left with surgery as your only option, let alone spinal fusion.

Sadly, many surgeons go right to spinal surgery and refuse to provide the patient with conservative treatment options. Worse yet, when one surgery fails, they are often offering up surgery number two, or three, or four, to “correct” the previous failed back surgery.

Does this require a frank discussion with your physician? Yes. But buyer beware as always. When the number of lumbar spinal fusions per capita is so incredibly high, you have to truly wonder if that is reflective of this nations’ lousy spines, or of the economic benefits of performing this costly procedure.

References:

Chou R, Baisden J, Carragee EJ, Resnick DK, Shaffer WO, Loeser JD. Surgery for low back pain: a review of the evidence for an American Pain Society Clinical Practice Guideline. Spine 2009; 34(10): 1094.

Wilson-MacDonald J. Should backache be treated with spinal fusion? The case for spinal fusion is unproved. BMJ 1996; 312(7022): 39-40.

Photo credits: planetc1

Related articles
  • Consumer's Guide To Health: The Treatment Of Plantar Fasciitis (allanbesselink.com)
  • Consumer's Guide To Health: The Treatment Of Frozen Shoulder (allanbesselink.com)
  • Mechanical Diagnosis And Therapy: A Systems Approach To Musculoskeletal Injuries (allanbesselink.com)
  • Back Pain: Why Direct Access To Physical Therapy Is A Critical Consumer Issue (allanbesselink.com)
  • Can You Spot The Serious Back Problem On This MRI? (allanbesselink.com)

Subscribe To My Newsletter

I'll share my latest thoughts, ideas, blog posts, and content with you every two weeks! It's free and it's 100% spam-free. How cool is that? What more can you ask for?

Subscribe Now

Besselink Project

  • Smart Sport
  • Smart Physio
  • RunSmart
  • RiffSmart
  • P1 Project
  • Innovanated

BP Manifestos

  • Smart Health Revolution
  • Vision Now

Breaking News

  • Should Normal Have Ever Been Normal?
  • The Power Trio: Language, Context, And Intent
  • The Forks In The Road Of Life
  • Mechanical Loading: The Ultimate Diagnostic Tool?
  • Austin's Musical Golden Goose

Most Popular Posts

  • The Deafening Silence
  • Evolution Or Revolution?
  • Learning How To Live
  • Patient Access To Physical Therapy And Groundhog Day
  • The Homeostasis Of Writing
  • McKenzie’s Derangement Syndrome In A World Of Pathoanatomy
  • Three Common Examples Of Self Image, Self Sabotage, And Comfort Zones In Action
  • Why HB 1263 Matters
  • The Flow Of Running, The Flow Of Life
  • One Nation – Under Gold
  • A Pause For Many A Cause
  • Civil Rights And Your Health
  • Own, Disrupt, Transform–Or Else?
  • Is Non-Evidence-Based Clinical Practice An Ethical Dilemma?
  • The APTA’s Vision 2020: My 12 Year Report Card
  • Think Big, Act Big
  • The Paradox That Is World Cup Soccer
  • Generation Z And Obesity
  • Direct Access To Physical Therapy: You Have It, Or You Don’t
  • Your Own Worst Enemy

Allan Besselink

Allan Besselink, PT, DPT, Dip.MDTAllan Besselink, PT, DPT, Ph.D., Dip.MDT has a unique voice in the world of sport, education, and health care, one that has been defined by his experiences as physiotherapist, mentor, McKenzie practitioner, innovator, author, educator, coach, patient, and athlete. Read more about Allan, contact him, get updates via email, or connect with him on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

RunSmart Book

Where To Buy RunSmartUp to 60% of runners will sustain an injury within any given year. Poor running mechanics, in conjunction with poor, ineffective and outdated training methods, can pose a significant injury risk. "RunSmart" was written to address these issues in the running community.

Featured Chapter

Clinical Orthopaedic Rehabilitation "Running Injuries: Etiology And Recovery- Based Treatment" (co-author Bridget Clark, PT) appears in the third edition and fourth editions of "Clinical Orthopaedic Rehabilitation: A Team Approach" by Charles Giangarra, MD and Robert C. Manske, PT.

PT Blog Awards

Top 5 finalist in three categories: "Best Overall Blog", "Best PT Blog" and "Best Advocacy Blog".

Copyright 2006-2022 Allan Besselink  | Terms Of Use | Privacy Policy |  Disclosure Policy |  FAQ

Powered By Mobius Intermedia