• Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Work With Me
  • Studio
  • Contact

Mechanical Diagnosis And Therapy: A Systems Approach To Musculoskeletal Injuries

Monday, 29 August 2011 13:13

A woman thinkingSystems thinking in health care forces the clinician to venture far from the shore in terms of their training and their beliefs. But in order to have a truly comprehensive system of health care, it will require clinicians to push the envelope of their thinking and let go of their belief systems. They will need to embrace assessment processes that allow the clinician to understand the behavior of the system as a whole, and a patient-centered treatment approach that emphasizes self care strategies.

Mechanical Diagnosis And Therapy (MDT) is a true systems approach to disorders of the musculoskeletal system. It is the next great revolution in musculoskeletal care, yet it also currently creates discomfort amongst many clinicians. Why? It forces clinicians to let go of the patho-anatomical model of care they have held near and dear for decades.

Every so often in science, a chance occurrence leads a clinician or researcher to an epiphany, which then pushes their thinking down a new road. Resistance is met from many groups, primarily because it challenges the commonly-held beliefs of the day. But the clinician pushes on, and the concept is advanced and eventually supported by the research. Robin McKenzie, a physiotherapist from New Zealand, was one such clinician.

With some astute clinical observations, McKenzie established certain consistent symptomatic and mechanical responses to repeated end range movements and sustained postures. He then used these responses to group patients into three primary diagnostic categories – posture, dysfunction, and derangement. He was able to describe mutually exclusive subgroups of patients based on principles of mechanical loading and pain production that have been well-established in cellular physiology. Diagnostic classification would then lead to an appropriate treatment plan which would include self treatment strategies. With an understanding of the behavior of the mechanical system, a clinician could effectively propose patient-centered self treatment strategies based on sound tissue loading principles.

The McKenzie Method has now received positive support in the research literature. Over the years, the McKenzie Method has also been mimicked, if not copied outright, by many other clinicians and groups. As they say, imitation is the greatest form of flattery.

McKenzie himself tried to define his own method based on the perceived hypothetical patho-anatomy involved. Having developed a broad approach to understanding the symptomatic and mechanical behaviors of the system (in true "systems thinking" style), even McKenzie had a desire to put it into the context of a patho-anatomical model! But what sets MDT apart - and what gives it its greatest power - is the fact that a patho-anatomical context is not necessary to describe a condition or its treatment.

As long as we have McKenzie's operational definitions, and we understand the dynamics of tissue loading, does it really matter what is causing the problem in a patho-anatomical context? A mechanical assessment identifies any specific red flags and precautions that would prevent the application of mechanical loading strategies. If the patient knows what "better" is in terms of function, mechanics and symptoms, then they can self-treat safely and effectively. Isn’t that the primary goal of musculoskeletal care?

McKenzie was, in effect, one of the first systems thinkers in medicine. As a result, MDT focuses on the behavior of the system - the "big picture" - instead of the micromanagement of patho-anatomical minutiae, impairments and mal-alignments that does not provide any greater insight nor value-added benefit for the patient’s ability to actually improve their outcome.

Photo credits: Wikipedia

Related articles
  • Systems Thinking In Health Care And The Failure Of Patho-Anatomy (allanbesselink.com)
  • Clinical Reasoning: When Beliefs Trump Evidence (allanbesselink.com)
  • Errors In Clinical Reasoning (allanbesselink.com)
  • The Smart Life Project (allanbesselink.com)
alt

Subscribe To My Newsletter

I'll share my latest thoughts, ideas, blog posts, and content with you every two weeks! It's free and it's 100% spam-free. How cool is that? What more can you ask for?

Subscribe Now

Besselink Project

  • Smart Sport
  • Smart Physio
  • RunSmart
  • RiffSmart
  • P1 Project
  • Innovanated

BP Manifestos

  • Smart Health Revolution
  • Vision Now

Breaking News

  • Should Normal Have Ever Been Normal?
  • The Power Trio: Language, Context, And Intent
  • The Forks In The Road Of Life
  • Mechanical Loading: The Ultimate Diagnostic Tool?
  • Austin's Musical Golden Goose

Most Popular Posts

  • The Deafening Silence
  • Evolution Or Revolution?
  • Learning How To Live
  • Patient Access To Physical Therapy And Groundhog Day
  • The Homeostasis Of Writing
  • McKenzie’s Derangement Syndrome In A World Of Pathoanatomy
  • Three Common Examples Of Self Image, Self Sabotage, And Comfort Zones In Action
  • Why HB 1263 Matters
  • The Flow Of Running, The Flow Of Life
  • One Nation – Under Gold
  • A Pause For Many A Cause
  • Civil Rights And Your Health
  • Own, Disrupt, Transform–Or Else?
  • Is Non-Evidence-Based Clinical Practice An Ethical Dilemma?
  • The APTA’s Vision 2020: My 12 Year Report Card
  • Think Big, Act Big
  • The Paradox That Is World Cup Soccer
  • Generation Z And Obesity
  • Direct Access To Physical Therapy: You Have It, Or You Don’t
  • Your Own Worst Enemy

Allan Besselink

Allan Besselink, PT, DPT, Dip.MDTAllan Besselink, PT, DPT, Ph.D., Dip.MDT has a unique voice in the world of sport, education, and health care, one that has been defined by his experiences as physiotherapist, mentor, McKenzie practitioner, innovator, author, educator, coach, patient, and athlete. Read more about Allan, contact him, get updates via email, or connect with him on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

RunSmart Book

Where To Buy RunSmartUp to 60% of runners will sustain an injury within any given year. Poor running mechanics, in conjunction with poor, ineffective and outdated training methods, can pose a significant injury risk. "RunSmart" was written to address these issues in the running community.

Featured Chapter

Clinical Orthopaedic Rehabilitation "Running Injuries: Etiology And Recovery- Based Treatment" (co-author Bridget Clark, PT) appears in the third edition and fourth editions of "Clinical Orthopaedic Rehabilitation: A Team Approach" by Charles Giangarra, MD and Robert C. Manske, PT.

PT Blog Awards

Top 5 finalist in three categories: "Best Overall Blog", "Best PT Blog" and "Best Advocacy Blog".

Copyright 2006-2022 Allan Besselink  | Terms Of Use | Privacy Policy |  Disclosure Policy |  FAQ

Powered By Mobius Intermedia