• Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • SMART
  • Community
  • Forum
  • Tools
  • Mobius
    • RunSmart
    • Podcast
    • Photos
  • Contact
Work With Me

Physiotherapy | Performance |  Mentorship |  Speaking | Events | SLP | News | Start

Tort Reform, Physicians, And Medicare In Texas

Friday, 28 October 2011 22:49
  • View Comments
Tort Reform, Physicians, And Medicare In Texas click to see full-size image

It is quite amazing how when you decide to run for President, all of your past political successes and failures are scrutinized in the public spotlight. Texas Governor Rick Perry has come under scrutiny – thankfully, I might add – for his health care policies in the state of Texas.

Governor Perry has been very vocal about his 2003 tort reform and the effect it has had on physician recruitment in Texas. But I think that the only doctor that would approve of this statement might be a spin doctor.

Has Governor Perry’s tort reform in Texas changed the health care playing field? Or has his health care agenda been a miserable failure in more ways than one? Does any of this bode well for his role in national health care reform should he become President?

The proposed goal of tort reform is theoretically simple: malpractice reform lead to lower costs, which then fosters more physicians coming to Texas, and more people having health insurance. At least that’s the line we keep receiving from the spin doctors.

Public Citizen, a national non-profit consumer organization, recently released a study on the effects of Perry’s “legendary” tort reform. I have summarized a number of their findings, adding my own comments along the way.

1. Tort reform has not decreased health care costs for anyone except physicians (via a 74.1% decrease in malpractice payments) and medical liability insurers. The TMA supported the legislation. Welcome to the presence of Big Medicine. Wait, there’s more …

2. Tort reform has not increased the number of physicians in Texas. Perry reported an influx of 21,000 new physicians. In the seven years prior to 2003, the per capita number of doctors was increasing at a rate of 9.3%. In the seven years following 2003, the rate dropped to 4.2%. These physicians are also not practicing in under-served areas.

3. Medicare costs in Texas have increased 42.7%, with the national increase at 37.8%. Medicare Part B spending was 40% higher in Texas than in the rest of the country. But it’s not just Medicare, because …

4. Health insurance premiums (as a whole) have increased at a faster rate in Texas than nationally. Since 2004, health insurance premiums have risen 13.1% faster in Texas than the nation as a whole.

5. Texas has had the highest number of uninsured people in the country, and it is getting worse. In 2003, 23.6% of Texans lacked health insurance; by 2010, this number had risen to 24.6%.

6. In Texas, 62% of primary care doctors no longer accept new Medicare patients. I can understand the debate over reimbursement rates. But did you know that when you choose not to accept Medicare patients, you also free yourself from the Stark laws that prevent physician self-referral? Intriguing coincidence?

So who benefited from the 2003 tort reform, Governor Perry? It is probably pretty safe to say that it wasn’t the health care consumers of Texas.

Photo credits: baslow

Related articles
  • Tort Reform Touted by Rick Perry Actually Increased Health Care Costs in Texas (firedoglake.com)
  • Texas Tort Reform and Texas Doctors (businessinsider.com)
alt

Did you enjoy this post?

If so, you will love my newsletter. Get blog updates delivered straight to your mailbox - along with exclusive content, updates, special events, and discounts!

Published in Subscribe to the RSS feed of Blog  Blog / Subscribe to the RSS feed of Smart Physio  Smart Physio
Tagged underconsumerhealth care reformTexaspolitics
blog comments powered by Disqus
back to top

Latest Blog Posts

  • A Pause For Many A Cause
  • Evolution Or Revolution?
  • The Homeostasis Of Writing
  • The Deafening Silence
  • Learning How To Live

Free Updates

Free Updates

Join Over 4800 Readers

Blog Menu

  • All Posts
    • Smart Physio
    • Rhubarb Diaries
  • Best Of The Blogs
  • Archive

Most Popular Posts

  • Three Common Examples Of Self Image, Self Sabotage, And Comfort Zones In Action
  • The Deafening Silence
  • Learning How To Live
  • McKenzie’s Derangement Syndrome In A World Of Pathoanatomy
  • Evolution Or Revolution?
  • The Homeostasis Of Writing
  • One Nation – Under Gold
  • Patient Access To Physical Therapy And Groundhog Day
  • The Flow Of Running, The Flow Of Life
  • Why HB 1263 Matters

Top 10 Smart Physio

  • Three Common Examples Of Self Image, Self Sabotage, And Comfort Zones In Action
  • The Deafening Silence
  • Learning How To Live
  • McKenzie’s Derangement Syndrome In A World Of Pathoanatomy
  • Evolution Or Revolution?
  • The Homeostasis Of Writing
  • Patient Access To Physical Therapy And Groundhog Day
  • The Flow Of Running, The Flow Of Life
  • Why HB 1263 Matters
  • Civil Rights And Your Health

Community Login






Forgot login?

Official Site

Help & FAQ

Help And FAQ
Terms And Conditions
Privacy Policy
Disclosures
Forum Rules

PT Blog Awards

Top 5 finalist in three categories: "Best Overall Blog", "Best PT Blog" and "Best Advocacy Blog".

Allan Besselink

Allan Besselink, PT, Dip.MDTAllan Besselink, PT, Dip.MDT has a unique voice in the world of sport and health care, one that has been defined by his experiences as physiotherapist, mentor, McKenzie practitioner, coach, innovator, author, educator, patient, and athlete. Read more about Allan, contact him, get updates via email, or connect with him on Twitter, Facebook, Google+ and LinkedIn.

RunSmart Book

Where To Buy RunSmartUp to 60% of runners will sustain an injury within any given year. Poor running mechanics, in conjunction with poor, ineffective and outdated training methods, can pose a significant injury risk. "RunSmart" was written to address these issues in the running community.

Featured Chapter

"Running Injuries: Etiology And Recovery- Based Treatment" (co-author Bridget Clark, PT) appears in the recently released third edition of "Clinical Orthopaedic Rehabilitation: An Evidence-Based Approach" by S. Brent Brotzman, MD and Robert C. Manske, PT.

License

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a CC BY-NC-ND License.

Visitors

Copyright 2013 Allan Besselink  | Terms Of Use | Privacy Policy |  Disclosure Policy | Powered By Mobius Intermedia